SIL vs SDA Governance Separation: What the NDIS Requires When You Deliver Both

If your organisation delivers both Supported Independent Living (SIL — the support services) and Specialist Disability Accommodation (SDA — the property), the NDIS Commission requires clear governance separation between these functions. This is one of the most heavily scrutinised compliance areas during SIL certification audits and is directly addressed in the new SIL Practice Standards Domain 3 (Practice Governance) and Domain 4 (Tenancy/Housing Agreements).

Source: NDIS Commission — Supported Accommodation

Why Separation Matters

The conflict is straightforward: when you own the property AND provide the support, you have a financial incentive to keep participants in your properties using your services. This can undermine participant choice — which is a foundational NDIS principle.

The Commission’s Own Motion Inquiry into Supported Accommodation found that:

  • 85% of all reportable incidents occurred in group home settings
  • Lack of governance separation contributed to quality and safety issues
  • Participants in dual SIL-SDA arrangements had limited genuine choice of support provider
  • Property management decisions (vacancy management, co-resident placement) sometimes overrode participant welfare considerations

What Governance Separation Looks Like

Structural separation

  • Separate decision-making authority for property (SDA) and support (SIL) functions
  • Where possible, separate management roles — the person managing properties should not be the same person managing support delivery
  • Separate reporting lines within the organisation
  • Separate financial reporting for SDA and SIL revenue and expenditure

Conflict of interest management

  • A documented conflict of interest policy specific to the SIL-SDA dual relationship
  • Procedures for identifying, declaring, and managing conflicts in individual participant situations
  • Board or executive-level oversight of conflict management
  • Regular review and audit of conflict management effectiveness

Participant choice protection

  • Evidence that participants are offered genuine choice of SIL provider — including providers external to your organisation
  • Transparent disclosure to participants about the dual relationship before they engage your SIL service
  • Participants can change their SIL provider without losing their SDA housing — the right to stay in their home is protected
  • Vacancy management decisions prioritise participant compatibility over revenue optimisation

What Auditors Assess

During your SIL certification audit, auditors will:

  • Review your conflict of interest policy for SIL-SDA specificity
  • Interview participants about their experience of choice — were they offered alternatives?
  • Examine organisational structure for genuine separation of functions
  • Review participant agreements to ensure tenancy and support are clearly separated
  • Check whether participants can change SIL provider without affecting their housing
  • Assess vacancy management processes for participant-centred decision-making

Alternative Models

Many providers choose to eliminate the conflict entirely by focusing on one function:

  • SDA-only model: You own and manage the properties. An independent, external SIL provider delivers supports within your dwellings. No conflict.
  • SIL-only model: You deliver support services in SDA properties owned by someone else. No conflict.
  • Dual model with formal separation: You deliver both but with board-level governance separation, independent management for each function, and documented participant choice processes. This is harder to implement and maintain but workable.

Sky Staff’s consultants can advise on the best structural model for your situation and help build the governance framework that satisfies auditor expectations.

Need Help with SIL-SDA Governance?

Sky Staff builds governance separation frameworks for dual SIL-SDA providers — conflict of interest policies, structural separation plans, and participant choice documentation. Free consultation.

Call 1300 317 040 | skystaff.com.au/contact-us

 

Find out how our NDIS Consulting services can help you

Please enter your details & we’ll get back to you within 1-2 business day.

Call Us

Get in touch!